Percy's Big Mistake

"The Fat Controller would never scrap a really useful engine, and you, Percy, are a really useful engine!"

- Thomas consoling Percy

Percy's Big Mistake is the seventh episode of the eighth season.

Plot
Percy is a very busy engine with many jobs to do, perhaps one too many jobs as the workload often makes him late. One evening, Percy arrives late at Brendam Docks and the dock manager decides to tell the Fat Controller about Percy being late. When Percy arrives back at Tidmouth Sheds that evening, he hears the Fat Controller talking to his driver, though he tries to ignore it. When the Fat Controller mentions "Percy must go to the scrapyard tomorrow". Percy is very worried; he quickly jumps to the conclusion that, due to his lateness, he is now going to be scrapped.

The next morning, Percy is frightened, though Thomas convinces him that he will not be scrapped as he is Really Useful. However, when Percy sees the time on the clock, he races out of the shed and goes to the Docks. At Brendam Docks, Percy is to collect some pipes, but Cranky is being slow and goes even slower when Percy orders him to hurry up. Once the pipes are in the trucks, Percy leaves too soon and the pipes fall off the trucks as they were not tied down. But Percy does not see this and delivers the empty trucks to Wellsworth. Then he collects some flatbeds with barrels full of tar to take to some workmen mending the road.

Percy pushes the flatbeds up and over Gordon's Hill, but he is going too fast. As a result, the trucks break away and crash into Gordon, spilling the barrels of tar all over him. Gordon is very cross at the mess, suggesting what the Fat Controller would think. Now Percy is convinced that he will be scrapped, so he runs away.

Soon Harvey clears up the mess and the Fat Controller arrives aboard Thomas. Gordon tells the Fat Controller that Percy ran away and Thomas tells the Fat Controller what Percy said to him about being scrapped. Soon a search party for Percy is underway. Whilst looking around on his branch line, Thomas knows where Percy might be - Tidmouth Sheds. Soon Thomas arrives at Tidmouth Sheds, where Percy is hiding. Percy begs the Fat Controller not to scrap him, but the Fat Controller comforts Percy by revealing the truth; he wanted Percy to take some trucks to the scrapyard and then, as a break from his busy schedule, Percy is to pull the mail for a whole week.

Percy is happy with his week-long mail run and promises to himself that he will not jump to conclusions.

Characters

 * Thomas
 * Gordon
 * Percy
 * Cranky
 * Sir Topham Hatt
 * Harvey (does not speak)
 * Edward (cameo)
 * James (cameo)
 * 'Arry and Bert (cameo)

Locations

 * Tidmouth Sheds
 * Brendam
 * Gordon's Hill
 * Centre Island Quarry
 * Wellsworth
 * The Coaling Plant
 * Knapford
 * Shunting Yards
 * Sodor River Bridge

Trivia

 * Stock footage from James Gets a New Coat is used.
 * A picture of a deleted scene shows Percy's pipes falling out by a canal instead of by the old crane.
 * In Finland, this episode is named "Percy's Mistake". In Japan, this episode is called "Debacle of Percy".

Goofs

 * When Percy passes through Knapford with the mail train, he bounces.
 * When Percy is pulling the mail he is wearing Thomas' tired face.
 * Surely, Percy's crew would've checked that the load of pipes were properly tied down before they left the docks.
 * When Gordon collides with Percy's train, a thin wire can be seen to pull the first flatbed into the air.
 * When the pipes fall out of Percy's trucks, you can see that a ramp was used to make them roll out.
 * Percy should have known that Sir Topham Hatt wouldn't scrap him.
 * There is not a brakevan on Percy's train in the last shot.
 * There is no way that Percy could so easily hear the Fat Controller talking to his driver through a window.