Talk:Marion and the Pipe/@comment-27420630-20140909194449

All I can say are a few goofs entitled to this episode:

1. Why would Marion re-bury the leaking pipe if it already had washed up the embankment from the start when she and Thomas went back to it?

2. The Fat Controller (if he did made an appearince, which ironically he didn't) would have obviously knew Marion was responsible for the broken pipe because she was repairing the embankment and would have told her that she shouldn't have re-buried the leaking pipe with dirt, because people and steam engines need fresh, clean water for washing and drinking.

3. The Workmen would have known and would have heard the sound of the pipe bursting water out and they would have stayed longer to fix and shut the water down to replace the broken pipe.

Not sure if any of these would count, but hey, they're all true. This episode didn't seem the best in my opinion.