Talk:The Old Station/@comment-24982355-20160407175447/@comment-25559529-20161230002313

It could be there, however, it's not known whether Oliver was travelling west of Callan or east. If it was west, this old station could be anywhere.


 * In Four Little Engines (the first appearance of Callan), Edward leaves Callan on the track next to the station and passes the station before going under the footbridge. In Oliver's Find, Oliver does the exact same thing. Edward ended up at Crovan's Gate. This means that the route Oliver was taking would go south on the Peel Godred line.
 * Contrary to the above, in Thomas and the Rumors, Thomas is on the Loop Line and ends up going through Callan the same way, implying that Oliver was travelling east of Callan.
 * In Oliver's Find itself, Oliver goes through the Fishing Village before ending up at Callan, implying he was going east.
 * However, in Sir Topham Hatt's Holiday, Percy leaves Callan the same way and ends up at Dryaw.
 * In Twin Trouble, Duck leaves the Sodor Ironworks and arrives at Callan facing the same way as Oliver, implying that Oliver was going east.
 * Likewise, in Percy's Chocolate Crunch, Percy leaves Callan in the opposite direction and ends up on Gordon's Hill.
 * Lastly, in It's Only Snow, Thomas leaves Callan in the opposite direction that Oliver went and ended up at locations we know aren't on the route through Misty Valley.

There seems to be more pointing to this old station being where you suggested it is (since it's four to two), but since two episodes suggest that it might not be the case, I don't think it should be definitively stated.